Every hiring decision tells a story. Recently, my team made one that I haven’t stopped thinking about, mostly because it reveals something every job seeker needs to hear: qualifications get you in the room, but who you are once you’re in the room is what actually moves you forward.
We interviewed two candidates for a role my team has been excited to fill. On paper, one was the obvious choice. Stronger technical skills. More experience. A clean, tidy resume that would make any recruiter sigh with relief.
And yet, we hired the other person.
Here’s why this matters for you, especially if you’re navigating a job search and wondering how to stand out when everyone else seems just as hungry for the role as you are.
Both were smart. Both were eager. Both were technically capable in their own ways. But the difference came down to something more subtle and far more important in today’s workplace.
If job searching were only about skills, Candidate B would be signing paperwork right now. But hiring is about more than checking boxes. It’s about building a team that works well together, solves problems, and grows without ego getting in the way.
That’s where things shifted.
PS: You can get the exact strategies I used to land my dream job, earn 4 promotions and 5x my salary straight to your inbox. Subscribe today.
Candidate B had only been at her current job a few months and said she wanted to leave because her ideas weren’t being implemented.
Here’s the thing: sharing ideas is great. Wanting to contribute is great. But expecting immediate adoption in your first few months is unrealistic. It takes time to earn trust. Time to understand the business. Time to learn why decisions are made the way they are.
If you talk about your employer like they’re the obstacle instead of the environment you’re learning in, it sends a message you may not realize: You’re not here to collaborate. You’re here to get your way.
When I asked about the best piece of criticism she had received, she shared the feedback… and immediately told me the person was wrong.
No curiosity. No reflection. No awareness of how the feedback could be useful.
Feedback is a gift, even when it stings. It means someone believes you’re worth investing in. If you shut that door, you also shut the door on growth.
And companies feel that.
Here’s the part I want you to pay attention to:
You can be confident without being rigid. You can be ambitious without being defensive.
Interviews aren’t just about proving what you’ve done. They’re about demonstrating how you’ll show up when things get tough, when someone pushes back, when a team needs you to pause before jumping in.
If you want to stand out in interviews, especially early in your career, bring these three things with you:
Be proud of your ideas. Share them. Show you think big.
But also show that you respect the process, the people, and the learning curve.
A hiring manager wants to know that you can evolve. That you’re coachable. That you don’t crumble the moment someone suggests a different approach.
This doesn’t mean being agreeable. It means being collaborative. Curious. Willing to learn and willing to listen.
Skills matter. But culture fit, attitude, and emotional intelligence matter more than most candidates realize.
Here are some simple ways to communicate humility, teamwork, and self-awareness in your answers:
These subtle shifts tell a hiring manager, “I’m someone who can grow, adapt and bring value without making everything about me.”
That’s the kind of candidate teams fight to hire.
The candidate we hired wasn’t the most technically skilled on paper. But she had the qualities that make a team stronger: curiosity, openness, emotional intelligence, and the ability to collaborate without ego.
If you're early in your career, this should feel energizing. You don’t need a perfect resume to get hired. You just need to show who you are and how you work with others.
Your soft skills, your character, and your emotional intelligence are not fluff. They are the deciding factors more often than you realize.
So as you prepare for your next interview, remember this:
Show your strengths.
Own your story.
But let your humility speak just as loudly as your ambition.
That balance is what gets you hired.